Design World

  • Home
  • Articles
    • 3D CAD
    • Electronics • electrical
    • Fastening & Joining
    • Factory automation
    • Linear Motion
    • Motion Control
    • Test & Measurement
    • Sensors
  • 3D CAD Models
    • PARTsolutions
    • TraceParts
  • Leadership
    • 2020 Winners
    • 2019 Winners
    • 2020 LEAP Awards
  • Resources
    • DIGITAL ISSUES
      • EE World Digital Issues
    • Future of Design Engineering
    • 2020 LEAP Awards
    • MC² Motion Control Classroom
    • Motion Design Guide Library
    • Podcasts
    • Suppliers
    • Webinars
  • Women in Engineering
  • Ebooks / Tech Tips
  • Videos
  • Subscribe
  • COVID-19

The big battle: Hydraulics vs pneumatics

By Paul Heney | March 20, 2014

Share

By Josh Cosford

gloves1Fewer topics in the fluid power realm garner more conversation than that of the differences between hydraulics and pneumatics. The two types of fluid power motivation are very similar, both in the use of a fluid to transmit mechanical energy and the executions using similar terminology, symbols and components.

Both hydraulic and pneumatic systems require a pump, although compressed air is first stored in receivers/tanks before being transmitted for use. Both systems use valves to control the force and velocity of the actuators, which are also similar to each motive. The real difference between hydraulics and pneumatics is the medium itself.

Contrary to popular belief, liquids are compressible. For hydraulic oil, a rule of thumb is that it will compress 0.5% for every 1000 psi that is exerted. However, for most applications this side of a flight simulator, we can consider it incompressible. If you push a large quantity of oil into a fixed volume, pressure will rise until something gives way, and this will happen very quickly.

The advantage of non-elastic oil being used to transmit mechanical energy is that transient behavior is excellent, and little energy is lost to compression of the fluid. This means as you pull a valve lever, the actuator starts moving immediately with little concern changes in fluid compression. You can consider a column of oil to move energy just like pushing a solid rod.
However, the downside to non-elastic oil is how difficult it is to move the fluid through valves, components and plumbing. Restrictions to flow of a liquid result if much higher resistance and energy loss than compared with pneumatics. The restrictive nature of oil is easily overcome by properly sized components matched to handle the flow of the system.

Another advantage of the high bulk modulus—the resistance to change in volume—of oil is its advantage over pneumatics is power density. Running a hydraulic system to 10,000 psi has little detrimental effect on performance compared to running compressed air to even 300 psi. Air compressors are limited to the amount they can compress air, and even with multi-stage compression, a lot of energy can be lost to heat.

Regardless, compressed air can do things that oil simply cannot. The compressibility of air can actually be used as an advantage, because when compressed air energy is released, it expands with vigor. And because the volume of air able to be moved though pneumatic valves and actuators is so high, especially when pressure drop is intelligently considered, the velocity of pneumatic actuators can be lightning fast.

When properly applied, pneumatically actuated machines are snappy and quick. Pneumatic applications are great for automated processes in the production of relatively light manufacturing and assembly—I say relatively because pneumatic applications can still produce thousands of pounds of force, whereas hydraulic applications can produce thousands of tons.

Additionally, the mathematics in applying hydraulics and pneumatics are someone different. Hydraulics are not concerned with compression ratios, and pneumatics are not concerned with pressure compensation. But for the most part, the difference between hydraulics and pneumatics is the fluid itself. However, you may get different answers if you ask a hydraulic specialist about pneumatics, or if you ask a pneumatic specialist about hydraulics. Feel free to tell me what you think about the differences between the two.

Josh Cosford, Certified Fluid Power Hydraulic Specialist, is with www.fluidpowerhouse.com.

Mobile Hydraulic Tips

About Paul Heney

Paul J. Heney, the VP, Editorial Director for Design World magazine, has a BS in Engineering Science & Mechanics and minors in Technical Communications and Biomedical Engineering from Georgia Tech. He has written about fluid power, aerospace, robotics, medical, green engineering, and general manufacturing topics for nearly 25 years. He has won numerous regional and national awards for his writing from the American Society of Business Publication Editors.

MOTION DESIGN GUIDES

“motion

“motion

“motion

“motion

“motion

Enews Sign Up

Motion Control Classroom

Design World Digital Edition

cover

Browse the most current issue of Design World and back issues in an easy to use high quality format. Clip, share and download with the leading design engineering magazine today.

EDABoard the Forum for Electronics

Top global problem solving EE forum covering Microcontrollers, DSP, Networking, Analog and Digital Design, RF, Power Electronics, PCB Routing and much more

EDABoard: Forum for electronics

Sponsored Content

  • With virtual commissioning, commissioning time and prototype waste is reduced
  • Master Bond Supreme 10HT High Strength, NASA Low Outgassing Approved Epoxy
  • Optimize, streamline and increase production capacity with pallet-handling conveyor systems
  • Drilling Rig OEM Benefits from a PLC with Edge Computing Technology: IIoT Case Study
  • #1 Reason for Retaining Ring Failure & How to Overcome It
  • Motion controllers: design from scratch or buy ready-made?
Engineering Exchange

The Engineering Exchange is a global educational networking community for engineers.

Connect, share, and learn today »

Tweets by @DesignWorld
Design World
  • Advertising
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Manage your Design World Subscription
  • Subscribe
  • Design World Digital Network
  • Engineering White Papers
  • LEAP Awards

Copyright © 2021 WTWH Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media. Site Map | Privacy Policy | RSS

Search Design World

  • Home
  • Articles
    • 3D CAD
    • Electronics • electrical
    • Fastening & Joining
    • Factory automation
    • Linear Motion
    • Motion Control
    • Test & Measurement
    • Sensors
  • 3D CAD Models
    • PARTsolutions
    • TraceParts
  • Leadership
    • 2020 Winners
    • 2019 Winners
    • 2020 LEAP Awards
  • Resources
    • DIGITAL ISSUES
      • EE World Digital Issues
    • Future of Design Engineering
    • 2020 LEAP Awards
    • MC² Motion Control Classroom
    • Motion Design Guide Library
    • Podcasts
    • Suppliers
    • Webinars
  • Women in Engineering
  • Ebooks / Tech Tips
  • Videos
  • Subscribe
  • COVID-19