Design World

  • Home
  • Technologies
    • 3D CAD
    • Electronics • electrical
    • Fastening & Joining
    • Factory automation
    • Linear Motion
    • Motion Control
    • Test & Measurement
    • Sensors
    • Fluid power
  • Learn
    • Ebooks / Tech Tips
    • Engineering Week
    • Future of Design Engineering
    • MC² Motion Control Classrooms
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Webinars
  • LEAP AWARDS
  • Leadership
    • 2022 Voting
    • 2021 Winners
  • Design Guide Library
  • Resources
    • 3D Cad Models
      • PARTsolutions
      • TraceParts
    • Digital Issues
      • Design World
      • EE World
    • Women in Engineering
  • Supplier Listings

Open Source CAD: Another perspective

By Evan Yares | August 2, 2012

Share

A few days ago, I opined that “If you’re looking for a really great open source CAD program, you’re going to be disappointed.”

Charles Warner, an engineer who uses a number of open source CAD programs, took issue with me on this. And he did it thoughtfully. Here’s what he had to say:

I suppose the idea of “really usable” is subjective. BrlCAD has been in use by the US Miltary and some of their contractors, for over 20 years. Yes, for someone coming out of a “commercial” environment (i.e., AutoCAD, Solidworks, etc.), there is a steep learning curve. I agree that OpenSCAD is not very useful, but I know of a community (Open Source 3D printing) that considers it most useful. For quick shop drawings of simple components, I find QCAD a whole lot faster than most commercial packages, because it isn’t bloated with all those exotic features that I never use. However, most of my current work is done in Salome, which, as you pointed out, was originally developed as a meshing program, but which has some very powerful and extensible geometry capabilities (I find Salome especially usable for generating 3D models from which I turn out *.stl files for my 3D printing projects). When I have a more complicated project, especially when looking at interacting parts, BrlCAD is my package of choice.

No, I am not going to design an airplane, or even an automobile with any of these packages, and, were I an architect, I would most likely invest in AutoCAD (not because it is the “best”, but primarily because that is what most local architects are using). Given the choice between Draftsight2 (the free 2D CAD program from Dassault) and QCAD for generating a quick shop drawing of a simple part, I find QCAD faster and more usable and just as capable for what I use it for. In fact, I find QCAD is much faster for most of my 2D needs than most of the commercial packages I have used over the years (I will admit that most of my experience with commercial packages is rather dated, and I am sure they have improved over the years since I have migrated to Open Source packages).

I have found that, over the years, as the commercial houses keep adding additional “features”, the packages become less and less usable. There is an “ancient” concept from the Unix world that software should do one thing only, and do it well. CAD is, as you point out, a very sophisticated and complicated process. However, the commercial approach of “one size fits all” winds up generating systems that are not very good at doing anything well (some of the commercial houses appear to be recognizing this, offering packages tailored to the architect or the mechanical engineer or the electrical engineer). It is unlikely that one will ever see an Open Source CAD package similar to the commercial offerings, because these commercial offerings violate the basic philosophy of “one thing done well”. What you can find in the Open Source world, however, are packages that can work very, very well for specific types of work, and one can select whichever package best suits the immediate needs.

“I would probably have a different perspective if I considered CAD a major revenue generator. However, for me, CAD is a “back room” tool which helps me accomplish the tasks that ARE revenue generators, and I need the simplist, fastest method of getting the ideas on paper.

So, what is “usable”? it all depends…

 

3D CAD Tips


Filed Under: 3D CAD World

 

Related Articles Read More >

The latest release of Siemens’ NX software
How to get everyone on the same page
Using CFD to optimize hydrodynamics performance for the America’s Cup
COMSOL announces events on simulation in biomedical technologies

DESIGN GUIDE LIBRARY

“motion

Enews Sign Up

Motion Control Classroom

Design World Digital Edition

cover

Browse the most current issue of Design World and back issues in an easy to use high quality format. Clip, share and download with the leading design engineering magazine today.

EDABoard the Forum for Electronics

Top global problem solving EE forum covering Microcontrollers, DSP, Networking, Analog and Digital Design, RF, Power Electronics, PCB Routing and much more

EDABoard: Forum for electronics

Sponsored Content

  • Renishaw next-generation FORTiS™ enclosed linear encoders offer enhanced metrology and reliability for machine tools
  • WAGO’s smartDESIGNER Online Provides Seamless Progression for Projects
  • Epoxy Certified for UL 1203 Standard
  • The Importance of Industrial Cable Resistance to Chemicals and Oils
  • Optimize, streamline and increase production capacity with pallet-handling conveyor systems
  • Global supply needs drive increased manufacturing footprint development

Design World Podcasts

June 12, 2022
How to avoid over engineering a part
See More >
Engineering Exchange

The Engineering Exchange is a global educational networking community for engineers.

Connect, share, and learn today »

Design World
  • Advertising
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Manage your Design World Subscription
  • Subscribe
  • Design World Digital Network
  • Engineering White Papers
  • LEAP AWARDS

Copyright © 2022 WTWH Media LLC. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media
Privacy Policy | Advertising | About Us

Search Design World

  • Home
  • Technologies
    • 3D CAD
    • Electronics • electrical
    • Fastening & Joining
    • Factory automation
    • Linear Motion
    • Motion Control
    • Test & Measurement
    • Sensors
    • Fluid power
  • Learn
    • Ebooks / Tech Tips
    • Engineering Week
    • Future of Design Engineering
    • MC² Motion Control Classrooms
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Webinars
  • LEAP AWARDS
  • Leadership
    • 2022 Voting
    • 2021 Winners
  • Design Guide Library
  • Resources
    • 3D Cad Models
      • PARTsolutions
      • TraceParts
    • Digital Issues
      • Design World
      • EE World
    • Women in Engineering
  • Supplier Listings