Design World

  • Home
  • Technologies
    • 3D CAD
    • Electronics • electrical
    • Fastening & Joining
    • Factory automation
    • Linear Motion
    • Motion Control
    • Test & Measurement
    • Sensors
    • Fluid power
  • Learn
    • Ebooks / Tech Tips
    • Engineering Week
    • Future of Design Engineering
    • MC² Motion Control Classrooms
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Webinars
  • LEAP AWARDS
  • Leadership
    • 2022 Voting
    • 2021 Winners
  • Design Guide Library
  • Resources
    • 3D Cad Models
      • PARTsolutions
      • TraceParts
    • Digital Issues
      • Design World
      • EE World
    • Women in Engineering
  • Supplier Listings

Linear Motor vs. Ball Screw

By Danielle Collins | December 2, 2014

Share

While ironless linear motors have been used in semiconductor and electronic applications for more than a decade, they are still viewed by many designers and OEMs as “niche” products. But the perception of linear motors as a costly solution for unique applications is slowly changing, as more industries are adopting them as replacements for ball screws in packaging, assembly, and part loading applications. And while the cost of linear motor technology has dropped over the past decade, the choice between a linear motor and a ball screw must take into account both the application’s performance requirements and the total cost of ownership over the life of the machine or system. Below are some of the key parameters to consider when comparing and choosing between ball screws and linear motors.

Where Linear Motors Excel

A linear motor is essentially an “unrolled” servo motor, where the rotor with permanent magnets becomes the stationary part (also called the secondary), and the stator becomes the moving part (also called the primary, or forcer), with coils encapsulated by epoxy. The most recognized advantage of linear motors is the absence of moving parts, which enables them to achieve much higher positioning accuracy and repeatability than ball screws. Another benefit in positioning accuracy is provided by the encoder. While ball screws typically use a rotary encoder mounted to the motor for positioning feedback, linear motors use a magnetic or optical linear scale for position feedback. The linear scale measures position at the load, which gives a more accurate reading of the actual position. For very high-precision applications, this more accurate position feedback can mean the difference between a part that meets specification and one that requires rework or scrap.

In a previous article, we discussed the tradeoff between speed and travel distance in ball screw applications. This is another area where linear motors provide an advantage. The allowable travel length of linear motors is theoretically unlimited, with other components of the system – linear bearings, cable management, and encoders – dictating the maximum travel. Similarly, the maximum speed and acceleration of linear motors are much higher than that of ball screws, with typical ratings up to 10 m/s velocity and 10 g acceleration, as long as other system components are sized correctly to meet these specifications. Despite the limits imposed by other components of the system, linear motors still outperform ball screws in applications that require both long travel length and high speed. They also have the advantage of allowing independently driven carriages (primaries) on the same secondary part. This is especially useful in some packaging applications, where the material to be packaged needs to be compressed before inserting it into the packaging medium (think of diapers packaged inside a poly bag).

Total Cost of Ownership Factors

Maintenance and reliability are important criteria in the total cost of ownership analysis, and linear motors offer several benefits over the life of the system. First, because they contain no mechanical moving parts, linear motors themselves don’t require maintenance. Only the linear support bearings require periodic lubrication, and many bearings are now offered with “long-term” lubrication or “lubed for life” options. The absence of moving parts in the drive system also improves reliability, as there are no rolling elements, bearing raceways or seals that will wear and require replacement over time.

With any linear system, it is important to consider the environment and the need for seals and protective covers. Linear motors are no exception, as they can be more difficult to enclose and protect than traditional ball screw assemblies. In many cases, however, as long as the linear bearings are properly sealed for the working environment, linear motors can withstand more aggressive contamination than ball screws.

For linear motors, the more critical environmental factor is temperature. Because the epoxy used to encapsulate the coils in an ironless linear motor does not readily dissipate heat, cooling may be required – either via forced air or water – to maintain an acceptable operating temperature for both the motor and the mounting structure. Some manufacturers use epoxies with high heat dissipation capabilities, but it is important to check the motor’s thermal dissipation and the effect that temperature will have on the motor’s available force.

More industries and applications are demanding long travel lengths, high speeds, and high positioning accuracy. While many types of linear systems can meet two of these three criteria, linear motors are the only technology that can provide all three without compromise. As throughput and total cost of ownership become the deciding factors in technology selection, designers and OEMs are becoming more familiar with linear motor technologies and helping them move from “niche” to mainstream status, alongside belts, rack and pinions, and even ball screws.

 

Linear Motion Tips


Filed Under: Actuators, Ball screws • lead screws, Encoders (rotary) + resolvers, Motors (linear)

 

About The Author

Danielle Collins

Related Articles Read More >

AMETEK-HKP-15000-6.2.22
New encoder option for AMETEK Haydon Kerk Pittman’s 15000 series actuators
Plus System ELM Unit
Rollon’s enhanced Plus Series actuators
LT22001_Rexroth-EMC-HP_IMAGE
New actuator for heavy loads from Bosch Rexroth
Voice coil actuator features high acceleration, zero cogging

DESIGN GUIDE LIBRARY

“motion

Enews Sign Up

Motion Control Classroom

Design World Digital Edition

cover

Browse the most current issue of Design World and back issues in an easy to use high quality format. Clip, share and download with the leading design engineering magazine today.

EDABoard the Forum for Electronics

Top global problem solving EE forum covering Microcontrollers, DSP, Networking, Analog and Digital Design, RF, Power Electronics, PCB Routing and much more

EDABoard: Forum for electronics

Sponsored Content

  • Renishaw next-generation FORTiS™ enclosed linear encoders offer enhanced metrology and reliability for machine tools
  • WAGO’s smartDESIGNER Online Provides Seamless Progression for Projects
  • Epoxy Certified for UL 1203 Standard
  • The Importance of Industrial Cable Resistance to Chemicals and Oils
  • Optimize, streamline and increase production capacity with pallet-handling conveyor systems
  • Global supply needs drive increased manufacturing footprint development

Design World Podcasts

June 12, 2022
How to avoid over engineering a part
See More >
Engineering Exchange

The Engineering Exchange is a global educational networking community for engineers.

Connect, share, and learn today »

Design World
  • Advertising
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Manage your Design World Subscription
  • Subscribe
  • Design World Digital Network
  • Engineering White Papers
  • LEAP AWARDS

Copyright © 2022 WTWH Media LLC. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media
Privacy Policy | Advertising | About Us

Search Design World

  • Home
  • Technologies
    • 3D CAD
    • Electronics • electrical
    • Fastening & Joining
    • Factory automation
    • Linear Motion
    • Motion Control
    • Test & Measurement
    • Sensors
    • Fluid power
  • Learn
    • Ebooks / Tech Tips
    • Engineering Week
    • Future of Design Engineering
    • MC² Motion Control Classrooms
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Webinars
  • LEAP AWARDS
  • Leadership
    • 2022 Voting
    • 2021 Winners
  • Design Guide Library
  • Resources
    • 3D Cad Models
      • PARTsolutions
      • TraceParts
    • Digital Issues
      • Design World
      • EE World
    • Women in Engineering
  • Supplier Listings